Co-operatively-owned Morning Star to develop new Scottish coverage and distribution

The Real Alternative to News International?

Amongst all the debate on Leveson, press ‘freedom’ and holding politicians to account, the main issue seems to have been forgotten - Press ownership. To be fair Leveson didn’t have it in his remit, but that in itself speaks volumes. 

Can anyone doubt that it was the sheer power of the News Corp empire that cowed most politicians? That drew corrupt officials, and managers to it like a moth to a flame? That power was built on its huge reach - a reach, let us remember, that was likely to have been extended via the full take over of BSkyB, had not the Millie Dowler hacking blown apart the cosy consensus of politician, regulator and bidder. Of course we should remember that News Corp held on to their 39.1% holding in BSkyB!

While an Independent press regulator, backed by statutory powers can be seen as an improvement (depending on how they are appointed and to whom they are accountable), the real solution lies in a media that is NOT dependent on big business, one that is accountable to its readers, and open to involvement by any of them.

A pipe dream? No, it exists, and is making a bold investment for the future here in Scotland. Tomorrow night (December 1), the launch of a new Scotland/North England print run of the Morning Star is being celebrated in style at the STUC building in Woodlands Road, Glasgow. As befits the only daily paper in the UK owned co-operatively by its readers, the night is being jointly organised by the Morning Star, and the Co-operative Party, 

The night will be a mixture of speeches (mercifully short, we are promised!) and music from some weel-kent faces. One addition to the list of speakers posted in my last blog is the leader of the Labour Party in Scotland. Johann Lamont is a Co-operative Party MSP, and has accepted an invitation from the party to speak.

Why not come along to back the real alternative to Murdoch’s millions! The night is free, but a collection for the Morning Star will be taken. Starts at 7.30pm. For further information foster631@btinternet.com.

Keep your culture on your left

After an enforced absence due to a family bereavement, the Captain leaps back into bloggery with news of some imminent cultural milestones, notice of another radical edge to next years Celtic Connections and a little nudge to radical groups and organisations to begin preparations for MayDay next year.

David Hayman marks the legacy of Bill Speirs

David Hayman

Later this week, on Thursday 29 November, the second annual Bill Speirs Foundation lecture is being given by Director and Actor (and good friend of Bill), David Hayman. This lecture is entitled Activate Your Humanity and Change the World. 

It is being hosted in the Deeprose Theatre (Room A005, Govan Mbeki Building) of Glasgow Caledonian University from 5.30pm. It will take the form of a lecture, followed by Q&A with David. There will be light refreshments afterwards, appropriately enough in the Govan Mbeki Garden Cafe! 

Entry is free, but ticketed, and a collection for the foundation will be taken. Tickets from http://billspeirs.eventbrite.com/. Any questions please contact Jaki Speirs on +44 (0)141 273-1610 or email jaki.speirs@gcu.ac.uk. 

This is the second in what is planned to be a series of annual events, marking the social, political, cultural and international legacy of former STUC General Secretary, Scottish Labour executive member, International campaigner, and 7:84 Theatre Company Director, Bill Speirs. It promises to be a great evening!

The Morning Star of Scotland

Another interesting event in the campaign to grow the left in Scotland is the launch of the Scottish edition of the Morning Star on Saturday 1 December at the STUC from 7.30 - 10.30pm. The Morning Star, as many on the left are aware, is the only left-wing daily paper in the UK. It is owned - not by multinational media empires, or even porn kings, but by its readers, like me, through a Co-operative (the People’s Press Printing Co-op). 

In recent years its sales here have been declining greatly, as the paper (along with other small-circulation dailies) has been refused access to a late night flight delivering the papers to Scotland. The lack of same-day availability has proved almost fatal, and led to a spiral of decline both in circulation and in coverage of Scottish issues

However, some of you may have started to notice it appearing on shelves in your local newsagents. Not only that, but these papers were currently dated! This is due to the Star management having taken two bold steps. Firstly, setting up a second printing source in Oldham, to ensure that the paper intended for Scotland and the North of England can access transport to these areas in time to get to us for the relevant day, and secondly appointing both a reporter on the staff with responsibility for Scotland (Rory MacKinnon) And a local journalist - the talented Malcolm Burns - who is keeping his eye on the scene in Scotland.

The Co-op funeralcare brass band

The event on Saturday is a Scottish Edition launch event. The St Andrew’s Weekend celebration is a mixture of speeches and musical celebration being organised jointly with the Scottish Co-operative Party. Again, it is a free event, but there will be a collection for the Star. Speakers are Richard Bagley (Editor of the Morning Star); Mary Lockhart (President of the Scottish Co-operative Party); Richard Leonard, (Political officer of the GMB), and Pat Rafferty, (Scottish Secretary of Unite the union). This part will be chaired by Agnes Tomie, (President of the STUC). 

Musical backing is being provided by the award-winning, Co-operative Funeralcare band, with some soloists also playing with prominent Scottish musician and composer, Eddie McGuire. Young performer, Marc Livingstone and evergreen singer Arthur Johnstone will complete the bill. For further information foster631@btinternet.com.

See you at both of these!!

Match This!

If you can’t get to Glasgow Caley on Thursday, and are in the Hamilton Area, you could do worse than to get yourself down to Hamilton Town House Library for 7.00pm. In a promising new library project, UNISON’s South Lanarkshire Branch and the local Leisure & Culture Trust are hosting an event with author Louise Raw. 

She will be promoting her new book, Strike a Light, telling how the women workers at Bryant and May in London's east end sparked the rise of new unionism and helped to build the modern trade union movement. 

Celtic Connections maintains its political cutting edge

It is good to see that the new programme for Celtic Connections, maintains the welcome radical edge started in last years festival. While a more detailed listing will come later, the return of Tony Benn, with a preview of his biographical film Will and Testament, 

particularly as he is joined by Comedian Mark Thomas to chair a Q&A afterwards, and with Scotland’s folk ‘royalty’ (though they wouldn’t thank you for that description), Sheena Wellington  and Arthur Johnstone, looks like a major highlight.

Sheena Wellington. The folk singers' folk singer

Arthur will also sing in Songs of Struggle. A collective series that emerged out of last year’s UCS Anniversary concerts. More detail later, but again a highlight of the programme. Concerts that also look good, include Red Cydeside, with Dave Swarbrick, and Scots in the Spanish Civil War, curated by Ian Macalman. More later!!

Prepare for MayDay

Finally, the potential for much of this cultural energy to re-emerge around next year’s MayDay celebrations in Scotland, looks hopeful. An early approach to a number of organisations from the Glasgow Friends of MayDay has started them preparing to stage events. 

The GFoMD also plan to build on last years successful MayDay programme, and in particular, are looking for bids from Trades Union Council’s outside Glasgow to see if we can’t develop the successful Concert into a short ‘tour’ around MayDay. Why not check what your TUC or campaigning group has planned, and get in touch with GFoMD via FairPley @ 0141 418 0562 or swright@fairpley.com or chrisbartter@btinternet.com 

Did Freedom of Information troubles tip the balance in EU advice U-turn?

In all the welter of comment on the current ‘scomnishambles’ or ‘advicis’ crisis in which the Scottish Government have embroiled themselves, I haven’t yet seen an analysis that looks at whether the withdrawal of their appeal to the Court of Session has a Freedom of Information rationale behind it, and in particular the role of the Deputy First Minister in the decision.

Nicola Sturgeon, wanting to
 avoid a fight on two fronts?

It is of course, entirely possible that the sudden withdrawal of the Scottish Government’s appeal against the Scottish Information Commissioner’s ruling, was due to the new Constitutional Supremo (Nicola Sturgeon) looking at the contradictions in their position solely from a Referendum Campaign perspective and deciding to ditch what was very likely to have become another failed appeal. After all the track record of the Scottish Government vs the (respective) Scottish Information Commissioners does not show a good strike record for the SG. 

As a lawyer, Ms Sturgeon cannot have relished going to the Court of Session to argue that the Government shouldn’t have to tell anyone whether they had obtained legal advice or not (not, you understand, what that advice was - the refusal to reveal that was already accepted by the SIC). Especially as it appears, they had not!!

So is it then a coincidence that Nicola Sturgeon, in the reshuffle, also inherited the responsibility for Freedom of Information? Or that this burden currently involves her trying to pilot a widely-criticised Amendment Bill through the Scottish Parliament? Or did the additional contradiction of trying to claim to be ‘improving’ the FOI legislation, while taking the Information Commissioner to court, add the final straw to this particular camel’s back?

Indeed the Amendment Bill itself isn’t getting the plain sailing that was envisaged by the Minister who introduced it (Brian Adam MSP). It has been widely criticised by a number of organisations including the Campaign for Freedom of Information in Scotland, the STUC and the Commissioner herself, and is shortly due to be debated at Stage 1 in the Parliament. The Finance Committee is currently considering its Stage 1 report. By the look of the evidence sessions, the new FOI supremo got a much harder time than her civil servants had prepped her for - and from some of her own side! 

The SNP reshuffle of committee appointments, hasn’t assisted the Bill’s progress much, although Bruce Crawford’s appointment onto Finance is widely seen as an attempt to shepherd the Bill through. Interestingly the other new SNP appointment is Jean Urquhart MSP. Her commitment to openness is well-known. Will her recent resignation from the SNP group mean the shortest ever residence on a parliamentary committee?

At the bottom of this row are three issues: 

1. That the Bill does not address the main problem of FOI - the increasing use of non-public bodies (private contractors, housing associations, voluntary sector bodies and arms-length organisations - ALEOs) to deliver public services, resulting in the removal of FOI rights from the public.
2. How the law should ensure that such bodies are automatically added.
3. The attempted introduction of a further ‘absolute’ (ie non-challengeable) exemption covering communications with the monarch or the heir to the throne.

Given that the previous (minority) SNP government had at least started to address the first two issues when they dropped it prior to the last election, campaigners were surprised and disappointed that when the now majority, government found time to introduce new legislation, it failed to deal with them.

After FOI defeat over the financial implications of Local Income tax; the embarrassment of the row over disclosing whether the Scottish Government recommended Brian Souter for honours, and now the climb down over EU legal advice, it seems that Nicola Sturgeon is well-versed in the dictum - if you’re in a hole, stop digging! 

"I'll do it again, you know."

However her boss today claims that he would again refuse to reveal whether he had advice in the future. A statement that appears only too obviously to be a return to the bad old days of arrogance that Messrs Pringle & Co have been trying to move him away from. It is also a very different approach from his deputy. So much so, that it raises speculation about who took the decision to drop the appeal, and whether both the FM and the DFM agreed with it! I guess any such division won’t be revealed either!

In these circumstances it also becoimes interesting to watched the progress of the FOI Amendment Bill. The Stage 1 report is in discussion, a parliamentary debate approaches. Might there still be twists and turns ahead in what the Government obviously hoped would be a technical, tidying-up bill?

FREE Film show is next step in Right to Know campaign

International Right to Know day
This Friday (28 September) is International Right to Know Day, and the Campaign for Freedom of Information in Scotland, is marking it with a FREE showing of the classic US film about a President's attempt to hide criminal activity, and how this was revealed publicly - All the Presidents Men.  

This takes place at the Glasgow Film Theatre at 2.50pm. Sponsored by UNISON Scotland.

This film - directed by Alan J. Pakula - stars the youthful-looking Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman as two journalists on the Washington Post (Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, who co-wrote the script) who break the story of President Richard Nixon's involvement in a criminal conspiracy to secure his re-election. While it starts with a minor break in at the National HQ of the Democratic Party, the story ultimately reveals a web of spying activity set up by the White House. Confirmation in the absence of FOI laws ('All White House transactions are confidential'), is obtained from a shadowy source - Deep Throat (who turned out to be the Deputy Director of the FBI!!

The screening is part of the CFoIS' campaign to extend the FOI laws in Scotland to cover outside organisations that provide public services, and will be followed by a discussion chaired by Rosalind McInnes, solicitor for BBC Scotland, with speakers from UNISON and CFoIS. 

Free tickets are available from the GFT box office on the day.

Contact the Campaign for Freedom of Information in Scotland for more information, or Chris Bartter on 07715 583 729

‘…gentle stirring sounds, Belied a deathly silence that lay all around.’

Spent an afternoon at Grantchester recently. An attractive village near Cambridge, probably best known either for the poet Rupert Brooke and especially for his poem The Old Vicarage, Grantchester. Or for the Pink Floyd track from Ummagumma - ‘Grantchester Meadows’, from which the title of this piece is taken.

Rupert Chawner Brooke, the
1910's answer to 'glitterati'.

Having walked there from Cambridge, we had a beer in one of the local pubs and then something to eat in the Orchard, where Brooke, and other of the ‘beautiful young litterati’ of the pre-first world war spent time. Indeed there is a small (and quite impressive) museum to Brooke there. It gave a view of an intelligent and privileged young man who in many ways seemed to have a particular gift for self delusion. He seemed to be constantly confused about who he should trust, love and support. He was apparently a socialist of a Fabian bent, but wrote five or six stirringly jingoistic military verses at the beginning of the first world war.

Indeed, these verses (along with The Old Vicarage, Grantchester) are probably the main reason for his fame. He was taken up by (among others) Winston Churchill who promoted the (by then dead) Brooke as the voice of The Soldier. 

In truth, it is unfair in the extreme to blame Brooke for this lionisation, and indeed given his lack of experience of the war, (he died in 1915 from  blood poisoning after Gallipoli, where we was not part of the landings. He is buried on the Greek island of Skyros) it may also be slightly unfair to blame him for the jingoism of his poetry. After all, both Wilfred Owen, and Siegfried Sassoon had to experience much of the ‘pity of war’ before they produced their greatest works, and Sassoon initially produced as militaristic verse as Brooke.

“To these I turn, in these I trust; 

Brother Lead and Sister Steel. 

To his blind power I make appeal; 

I guard her beauty clean from rust.” The Kiss

Charles Hamilton Sorley

However, there was another poet early in the first world war who not only saw the futility and horror before having to spend years in the trenches, but also possessed the objectivity to express that as a general truth. The objectivity of Owen’s Strange Meeting, rather than the direct attack of Sassoon’s Base Details if you like.

Charles Hamilton Sorley, like Brooke, died young (also in 1915) and had little or no time to experience the horrors of war, yet in the short time he did have he produced two remarkable poems. All the hills and vales along, and When you see millions of the mouthless dead, are significant for both their prescient recognition of the futility of war and the bitter sarcasm with which Sorley lampoons the pastoral glories of many of the pro-war poets.

How does this happen? That a less insightful poet receives far greater recognition than a better? Is it to do with privilege? Hardly, Sorley was the product of the same public school/oxbridge upbringing as Brooke (although Marlborough College/Oxford vs Brooke’s Rugby School/Cambridge). He was, as some might have guessed, Scottish - born in Aberdeen - but that wasn’t hugely significant in his upbringing. 

Rupert Brooke (a la the Archers)

It is surely down to the illusion perpetrated by the establishment in using Brooke’s poetry to shore up their false image of the glory of war. Even now, a statue of Brooke in the grounds of the Old Vicarage in Grantchester, shows him in battledress holding a book! Yet his experience of frontline warfare was limited to one day of limited action during the evacuation of Antwerp! 

Mind you, if the illusion of Brooke was false, it was largely perpetrated by other people. The family who now own the Old Vicarage, Grantchester are the Archers, Lord Jeffrey, and Lady Mary. Certainly Jeffrey is a literary figure who requires no outside assistance to create an illusion of qualification, or even truth!

Tales from the city-the fourth. Transports of delight.

Thank you, driver

A lesser-profiled event at the Assembly Rooms was a series of performances of Love Letters to the Public Transport System. Produced by the National Theatre of Scotland, this is a gem of a production, written, produced and performed by Molly Taylor. The premise of the monologue are a number of individual stories about love and busses, which spark other thoughts about the use we make of trains and boats and planes (or, well, busses), and the people who drive them. 

Molly Taylor

The piece cleverly interweaves individual's stories with Molly’s own attempts to contact bus and train drivers who have taken her on key journeys - and her lack of success in doing so. What it also sparked for me was a memory of my first impressions of Glasgow busses. Arriving in the city from the ‘underbelly of British capitalism’ I was struck by two things. Firstly, how no-one in Glasgow ever seemed to press a bell to get the bus to stop, getting up and standing by the driver (or on the platform) seemed to be the practice; but secondly how everybody thanked the driver on their way off! 

While the bell etiquette has changed, the #thankyoudriver  seemed to me then, (and still does) a remarkable practice that is not repeated anywhere else (Molly confirms that it isn’t the practice even in a similar city, like Liverpool). She ascribes the difference (in part) to the fact that elsewhere passengers exit busses through a centre door away from the driver, but although this has some superficial appeal, surely in Glasgow the history as elsewhere, was that busses had back platforms. What did Glasgow’s passengers do to express their gratitude then? Shout down the bus? Pass thanks to the conductor? No, I thought then, and still think that it is a positive decision by Glasgow (and, she says, other central belt passengers) to go out of their way to acknowledge people working on their behalf in public services. Despite much-publicised (and serious) increases in the abuse of our public service workers, and the rising tide of those insulated from public contact by headphones and MP3 players, it continues. Long may it do so.

The performance also touches on another (and probably linked) aspect of public transport and our reaction to it. Molly finds it impossible to actually track down the particular drivers that took her about. She does speak to drivers who have won service awards, nominated by their passengers for their care and work, but it seems very difficult to get to an individual driver (after the event) to say thanks. Or even to get the companies to respond! She contrasts this with the facilities set up to process, deal and respond to complaints. Are we become the destroyer of services? Are we so concerned with our own needs that we fail to tell people thanks for what they do for us? And more seriously, is there no room for public service operators to set up ways to reach individuals with praise, rather than only blame?

Love letters has already performed in Glasgow at the Tron, if it reappears near you, get along to see it. Quirky, humorous and ultimately positive, it is beautifully written and acted. It itself, goes some way to attempt to redress the balance. 

Tales from the city-the second, (and third). Talking (about) books.

You CAN judge a book by looking at the cover

One of the main reasons for going to Edinburgh at festival time, is to take in the decidedly civilised ambience of the Book Festival. Unlike the somewhat frantic hubbub of the city streets, Charlotte Square remains an oasis, and the events scheduled have a good chance of being successfully as advertised, something often lacking in the Fringe! (Mind you they do need to provide more seating in the cafe/bar areas!)

To the Square first to listen to Jon Gray and Jamie Keenan, expound their Twenty irrefutable theories of book cover design. Keenan and Gray are both exceptional book cover designers, whose styles seem to be both very different, and to fit together neatly. (see Jamie Keenan designs here http://www.keenandesign.com/index.html, and some Jon Gray here http://bookcoverarchive.com/gray318). It is no surprise to find they have previously worked together, and you will find yourself spotting books that you have noticed in shops (which after all, is the point) as you look at their portfolios.

Aaaaahhhhhh!!

The ‘Twenty theories’ covered a vast range of ideas, and principles, from standard design rules (on use of white space for example), to specific book considerations (not revealing important plot twists etc.). However the presentation needed trimming to get the best effect in the 45 mins available. Not yet available on line or in print (a book is in preparation), my favourite was the last. #20 When all else fails, use a picture of a cute kitten !  Jen Bowden in the Guardian has helped by listing the theories here. http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/booksblog/2012/aug/16/book-cover-theories-edinburgh-festival 

Another book-related presenting pair (aren’t they all book-related? Stop splitting hairs!) were John Crace and John Sutherland. Crace is the Guardian’s ‘Abbreviated Books’ columnist, parodying and condensing modern and classic fiction. He treated us to both David Copperfield, and Antonia Fraser’s memoir of Pinter, showing both sides of his work - homage to satire! The fact that he is a great Spurs fan too, helps my appreciation of him immensely!

John Sutherland

John Sutherland, was an academic lecturer in English Literature. The author of ‘Can Jane Eyre be happy’ and Where was Rebecca shot?’, he is used to approaching the classics from unusual angles. His current book Lives of the Novelists sets out to provide a huge history of fiction in 294 lives. As his examples from Stevenson and Scott proved, his penchant for an oblique eye has not been lost!

Future Festival Blogs

One of the problems re blogging on festival events is that if you’re at them, you’re not talking about them, and before you get round to do that, they’re finished (a bit like the 1960's really).  So I thought I’d do some more reflective stuff (code for too lazy to meet deadlines - lets hear it for Douglas Adams!). Look out for blogs on Past Labour ‘Leaders’, Oratory in politics, Franco and Spain and (in particular) Saying ‘Thanks’ to bus drivers.